All our lives were impacted by COVID-19, but what was the impact on KeyForge sales? There was a very technical post last month, this one is intended for everyone that cares about KeyForge, but not the details of how to create models.
500 000 fewer decks registered during COVID
This shouldn’t come as a surprise to anyone, during COVID, with the world going in lockdown there were fewer decks registered. With local game stores closed, in person games were hard if not impossible at times and the competitive scene died out entirely. So no decks are being purchased for sealed play and there was no need to buy a bunch of deck to find that one with the combo that could take you to the top of the leaderboards. With people unable to get together and play, they play less and the decks they do purchase will last longer as the novelty doesn’t wear off nearly as fast.
The graph below shows, in blue, how many decks were registered in the master vault since the release up until this article was posted. The gray line indicates how many decks the model predicts would have been registered had COVID-19 never happened. The area between the lowest and highest prediction is shaded in gray and shows the uncertainty of the model.
So the model fits the real data like a glove before COVID-19 measurements got into effect (which is good, it would be a very poor model if it didn’t) and as it projects further into our hypothetical scenario the uncertainty grows (which is expected). It shows that without COVID-19 there would have been around 3.16 million decks registered on August 15th, 2021. With the worst prediction at 2.99 million and the best 3.31 million, which makes the actual number of decks registered at that date, 2.43 million look rather pale in comparison.
So Fantasy Flight Games sold a substantially lower number of KeyForge decks during this period. Obviously this isn’t good for the game, without a global pandemic there would have been at least half a million more decks registered. Note that the number of lost sales is even higher, as not every deck sold is necessarily registered.
The interest in KeyForge didn’t diminish
Do you notice the little nicks in the graph above? Those bumps coincide with new sets being released. With every set being preceded with additional advertisement to create a bit of hype, and simply new cards coming out gets people excited to pick up new decks. The model includes the interest there is to buy new decks upon release, and we can compare this between sets. (Technical details can be found in the previous post, with the latest model available on GitHub )
This graph is a bit harder to grok than the previous one, so let’s pick it apart slowly. Each bell curve represents the interest in the different sets, the more the curve is shifted to the left, the lower the interest was, the more to the right the more decks were sold due to the release of that set. The shape of the curve shows where the model thinks the real value is, so it is more likely to be near the top of the curve than near the bottom. Overlapping curves mean there is a rather large chance there was no real difference between the two sets. The technical term for these curves are probability density functions.
The interest in Call of the Archons, the very first set, is huge compared to the others. Releasing a new game, by Richard Garfield, Ph.D. himself, can have that effect. It being a new game also requires people to pick up a few decks to have a variety of games. So the fact that no-one had a collection yet also made the threshold to buy decks early on lower than right now, where some players have already acquired dozens if not hundreds of decks.
However, we see only minor differences in the interest in other sets released before (Age of Ascension and Worlds Collide) and sets released during the pandemic (Mass Mutation and Dark Tidings). The graphs overlap too much to make a call which ones are worse or better than others with confidence. Which is a good thing here! So, we can conclude that the interest in new KeyForge releases hasn’t faded because of a viral outbreak!
KeyForge is a game intended to be played in person. So it is not surprising that with local game stores and tournaments abruptly becoming unavailable the rate of decks being registered dropped considerably. This must have lead to considerable losses for both game stores and Fantasy Flight Games which produces KeyForge. With 500 000 less decks registered the last year and a half, it also creates the impression that interest in the game died. Though when digging deeper into the data that is clearly shown to be incorrect. People still pony up cash to buy new decks upon the release of a new set as before the pandemic. Which suggests the game is very much alive, but incentives to buy more product between releases (sealed and competitive play or simply the ability to go out, sit in front of someone at the store and play) simply weren’t there. Hopefully that is about to change soon again with life restrictions being lifted and the World Championship coming up in 2022 !
Note that this is all about the number of registered decks, if you are interested in the total number of printed decks, have a look a this post.
This post is unofficial Fan Content. The literal and graphical information presented in this project related with KeyForge is copyright of Fantasy Flight Games (FFG). 4DCu.be is not produced by, endorsed by, supported by, or affiliated with FFG.
Liked this post ? You can buy me a coffee